Angel Beats Review

Summery: Otonashi wakes up in a strange world without any memories and a girl next to him holding a gun. When he’s ask what’s going on, she tells him that he’s dead, and introduces him to the strange sort of purgatory that they’re stuck it. She then invites him to join her in her battle against god. With nothing to lose, he teams up with the girl to figure out what’s going on and to hopefully regain his memories.

Why I Picked It Up: Angel Beats was one of the most hyped shows of the spring season and had an absolutely stunning first episode.

Why I Finished It: I’m going to combine the positives and negatives here as Angel Beats is a very complicated show to describe. Angel Beats is a show that should have been twice the length it was, and the creators tried to stuff too much in their storyline. As a result, the pacing was off, the storyline suffered, and the series was given a disjointed and chaotic feel. Yet, the creators still tried to do something with the anime, and their enthusiasm for the series came through, and I have to give them credit for that.

Oddly enough, while I doubt the disjointed chaotic feeling was their intent, it ended up fitting the series very well, so who it harmed the series in some ways, it ended up working to the series benefit in others.

Furthermore, I really liked the characters. Even if they weren’t the best developed, they were still incredibly likable, and one could sympathize with their plight of being stuck in a confusing world while they still had this inner anger. A lot of work was put into making the minor characters stand out with small and silly but noticeable quirks. The way the relationships grew between the characters, while not perfect, was enjoyable as well. In the end, the characters are what I liked best about the series, and what kept me coming back every week.

Who Would I Recommend This To: Anyone getting tired of the same old same old in anime should give this a shot. It’s not perfect, but it tries, and in the end, I really liked this.

My rating: 4/5- I Loved This

Side Note: Why I gave this a 10 on MAL is I’m starting to give series a 10 that I want to keep in mind should I decide to compile a ‘Top Anime’ list so they stick out among my watched anime.

Goodbye Angel Beats, and thanks for not only a great series, but some great fan art!

3 Comments

Filed under Angel Beats, Comedy, Drama, Middle/High School, Mystery, Romance, Slice of life

3 responses to “Angel Beats Review

  1. Wollff

    I have to agree to a lot of what you say, though in the end my verdict would be that the series messed up big time. I blame the writer.

    As you mentioned, the fact that the series could easily have filled another season gives it a rushed and chaotic feel toward the end. But even if those kinks in pacing at times fit the feel of the story, I can’t understand how a writer can load up a thirteen episode show with three lead and seventeen (!) side characters. And still think that this might have been a good idea.

    What drives me nuts isn’t that Angel Beats is a bad anime. It isn’t. What makes me so mad that I have to vent on a random blog about it, is the fact that it easily could have been better. Ditching half its cast, avoiding meandering plotlines, and taking one idol instead of a whole band are basic revisions which would (apart from the writer’s ego) not have hurt anyone and could have cured all the show’s problems.

    I will forever hold a grudge against that writer. He made something that could have been great into something okay by refusing to adapt a 26 episode story to a 13 episode format. The fact that this could easily have been done, just rubs salt into the wound.

  2. Pingback: Angel Beats, episode 13 – Party of Five | Blogging about Anime | Rabbit Poets

  3. Sang.

    I’m definitely inclined to agree. Angel Beats is by far the single shortest anime I’ve ever seen, and though I throughly enjoyed it the storyline was by far weaker towards the end with the somewhat rushed revelations about the world, characters about themselves.

    I mean, how Yuri and Tenshi suddenly characterise themselves to the stereotypical giggly and shy schoolgirl personality we see so much really was a letdown in how they played such a huge role in the progression of the storyline, and in relation to the protagonist alone. In the last 3 episodes it ultimately felt very, very rushed with bits of what I felt could have been exceptional storytelling missing entirely between main acts.

    I’d look forward to the writer’s future projects if he learns from the mistakes he made in AngelBeats!, and helps create even more enjoyable anime’s in the future.

    – Sang.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s